There may be a kind of self
... but not the one we think of. In a conversation with Robert Wright and Stephen Asma the latter speaks about research of the brain in animals that has shown that there be an early part of the brain that can be seen as a permanent self. Both for humans and animals, and anyway as long as we stay alive. The thoughts and the stories we tell about our selves are not a self, for instance because of our tendency to deceive our selves. So we have much in common with other animals and maybe even with plants. A core-self that not has anything to do with personality or language - but probably with feelings and cravings. So we cannot get rid of the cravings with thought, but we can handle them... Maybe not always with sitting meditation, exercise or drawing may sometimes be better..... But as a lay Buddhist Asma can drink some whiskey in the evening if he's not attached to it... As the craving never will go away why not respect them a little... Here's the conversation (